On a night when the moon hid behind thick clouds, Sarah sat alone in her candle-lit room. The wind pressed against the windows, coaxing the flames to dance, shadows stretching across every wall, creeping into corners where unknown fears lurked. She was sixteen and new to this old house, her parents having moved after her father's promotion. The locals spoke little to outsiders—they only warned not to wander after midnight, and never to speak to her own reflection.
Sarah was clever, restless, and believed none of it. She prided herself on logic, on being older now than childish superstitions could touch. So when her best friend Kayla dared her over text to try “the mirror legend”, Sarah laughed. In every haunted tale the kids at school swapped, mirrors sat as the borderlands between worlds; supposedly, if you looked into one at midnight and whispered, "Who is there?", something answered back.
The clock read 11:45 PM. Sarah’s parents slept in the room across the hall, oblivious. Her room was safe, she thought—her books stacked, her photos on the dresser, and a single, antique mirror found in the attic now resting against the wall. Lightning flickered as another storm rolled in, thunder rumbling like a warning. She lit a second candle, watching the flickering light double as it reflected in the glass.
Ten minutes passed. Sarah’s heart sped; she told herself she was bored, not nervous. The candle’s glow spilled gold onto the mirror. The quiet deepened until she felt she could almost hear another breath, except she knew she was alone. Seconds ticked by. At last, the clock struck twelve—a low, mournful chime echoing through the hall.
Sarah stood before the mirror. Her own face stared back, pale and earnest, eyes too wide. She hesitated, then whispered, “Who is there?” The silence pressed against her ears, almost deafening. She waited, her own breathing louder, her reflection flickering as the flame stuttered.
Then, impossibly, the mirror darkened as the candle wavered. Sarah’s reflection blinked—but she hadn’t. The air grew colder. Suddenly, she heard it: a soft, slithering voice, low as the wind—“Behind you...”
Sarah jerked around, expecting a prank, Kayla sneaking in, her parents catching her out. But there was nothing there. Just her room, just shadows, just the storm. But the air felt different—a chill that bit through her pajamas, a heaviness, almost as if someone else was holding their breath, waiting.
Swallowing her fear, Sarah turned back to the mirror. For a split second, she saw a second figure next to her reflection—a shadow, tall and thin, with a smile that gleamed too white, too wide. Before she could truly see, lightning flashed outside and the entire house shuddered. The shadow vanished, her own reflection returned, but Sarah was not alone in the feeling that something had crossed over.
She scrambled back onto her bed, hastily blowing out the candles, but the room wouldn’t warm, the shadows wouldn’t fade. She tried to reason. It was late, her mind played tricks, the legends were just stories. But as she lay, sleepless, her eyes drifted back to the mirror once, twice, then every few minutes. Sometimes, she thought she saw movement—a flicker beside her own reflection, a pair of eyes gleaming low.
The next day, Sarah tried to forget. She told Kayla everything, laughing it off, but her friend grew quiet, confessed that she herself had tried the mirror game once and stopped when her own reflection seemed to mouth words she couldn't hear. Kayla begged her not to play again.
But curiosity nagged at Sarah. She researched mirror legends—the Russian myth of the vampire’s reflection, the Japanese tale of the “ghost behind glass”, the old English rhyme, "Ask your truth at midnight’s door/And lose what’s yours for evermore." She barely noticed that the house grew colder as dusk came, and that her own reflection seemed increasingly distant, slow to mimic her movements.
On the third night, unable to help herself, she tried again. The clock ticked toward midnight. This time, she set up her phone to record, lit three candles, and stared into the mirror. Her reflection blurred and twisted as the flame flickered. Fighting panic, she whispered again, “Who is there?”
Nothing—until the reflection’s lips curled into a cruel smile and whispered, perfectly timed, perfectly echoed: “You invited me in.”
Just then, Sarah heard footsteps in the hallway. She spun, heart pounding. Her mother called out, voice muffled. “Sarah, are you all right?”
“Yeah, just a bad dream!” Sarah lied, covering the mirror with a sweater. She left the candles to burn out, crawled into bed, and tried not to cry.
Over the next week, things got worse. Sarah’s family felt the house grow colder. Shadows fell at strange hours. Sarah herself felt watched, especially at night. Once, in the bath, she saw a pale face reflected behind her own in the bathroom mirror. Another time, while brushing teeth, a phantom hand mimicked hers before vanishing.
Convinced she might be losing her mind, Sarah decided to stay awake all night. At midnight, she sat staring into the antique mirror. Lightning flashed, thunder roared, and she saw not her own reflection, but the shadowy figure, smiling.
“What do you want?” she whispered.
The reflection did not move its lips but spoke clearly in Sarah's head: “To remember. To return. You opened the door.”
Desperate, Sarah researched how to undo old legends. She found advice: break the mirror, use salt, burn sage, pray, leave the house. She tried everything. She sprinkled salt around the mirror, burned sage until the smoke stung her eyes, but each midnight her reflection grew stranger, and the shadow behind grew clearer.
The final night, Sarah wrote a note and hid it behind the mirror: “If you see this, never play the mirror game.” Then, with trembling hands, she lifted the mirror and smashed it on the floor. For a moment, it sounded like screaming—shards danced over her carpet, and the shadow vanished.
The house grew warmer. Shadows faded. Sarah slept for the first time in a week. But sometimes, just at the edge of sleep, she thought she could hear a voice whispering from nowhere, begging to be let in. She never kept an uncovered mirror in her room again.
Years later, Sarah found her old phone in storage. On it, a midnight video: the flickering candles, her own pale face, and for a split second, behind her, a second smiling silhouette, eyes gleaming red. She deleted it.
The legend of Black Willow Lane lived on—but Sarah always warned new friends: never ask your mirror, “Who is there?” unless you are prepared for someone to answer.